Classifiers as packaging geometries

Japanese is an obligatory classifier language. Same surface “number + unit” can realize two packaging geometries (Oho 2019). Counters are inert for verbal valency.

Two positions

Prenominal · Num-Cl-no N 三冊さんさつの本ほん san-satsu-no hon · ‘three books’ · Num+Cl as NP adjunct (Oho)
Postnominal · N Num-Cl 本ほん三冊さんさつ hon san-satsu · ‘three books’ · Num and Cl as extended-nominal heads (Oho)
Floating · N-Case Num-Cl 本ほんを三冊さんさつ買った hon-o san-satsu kat-ta · ‘(I) bought three books’ · float of the Measure complex, not an extra verbal object

People counter 人 — irregular spell-out, same geometry

Num+CLFormNote
1 person一人ひとりSuppletive
2 people二人ふたりSuppletive
3 people三人さんにんRegular -nin
Prenominal三人さんにんの学生がくせいGeometry A
Float学生がくせいが三人さんにんFloat of complex

Sortal + mensural — still no extra verbal arity

Project MeasureP example: sortal Measure on Theme + mensural Price as Instr can co-occur. Price is not a second Acc object of uru (Double-o banned). Four distinguished participants + two Measure complexes ≠ six verbal arguments.

SPECULATIVE mnemonic (optional). “Kanji counters look like frozen packaging labels for sortal units.” Collapse if treated as evidence that orthography is MeasureP.
Sources. Oho 2019 PACLIC; Watanabe 2006 NLLT; Sudo 2016; project MeasureP excerpts. Orthography: 人 冊 本 個 台 枚 匹 円 — correlate only.

VN + light suru — Argument Transfer

Light suru assigns Acc and inflection but no θ-roles. Process nominals (often Sino-Japanese, kanji-written) supply the θ-grid. Argument Transfer redistributes roles across Noun and Verb domains (Grimshaw & Mester 1988).

Core paradigm — VN licenses the array

(1) Talk — Goal outside JohnはMaryに話はなしをした John-wa Mary-ni HANASHI-o shita · ‘John talked to Mary.’ · VN 話
(2) Departure — Source outside Johnは東京から出発しゅっぱつをした John-wa Tookyoo-kara SHUPPATSU-o shita · ‘John departed from Tokyo.’ · VN 出発
(3) Warning — Goal + clausal Theme Johnは村人に[狼が来ると]警告けいこくをした John-wa murabito-ni [ookami-ga kuru-to] KEIKOKU-o shita · ‘John warned the villagers that the wolf was coming.’ · VN 警告

Observation (G&M): The argument array varies with the Noun, not with suru. Suru contributes inflection + Acc, not the θ-grid.

Transfer schematic for 警告

keikoku (Agent, Goal, Theme)
    Transfer →
keikoku (Theme)  +  suru (Agent, Goal) (acc)

Surface arity ≠ piece arities

ExpressionVN θ-grid (approx.)suru aloneSurface clause
話をする (+ Goal)Agent, Goal( )Agent + Goal
出発をする (+ Source)Agent, Source( )Agent + Source
警告をする (+ Goal + S′)Agent, Goal, Theme( )Agent + Goal + Theme
到着をする (+ Goal)Theme, Goal( )Theme + Goal

Punchline: Counting surface DPs does not tell you the arity of either vocabulary item in isolation. Transfer packages roles across Noun and Verb domains.

Also a VN (opaque compound neighbor) 勉強べんきょうする benkyoo-suru · ‘to study’ · often incorporated; see compounds panel for fossil opacity of 勉強
SPECULATIVE mnemonic only. Kanji VN stems look like portable argument packages plugged into a light verbal host.
Sources. Grimshaw & Mester 1988 LI 19(2). Most productive light-suru VNs are Sino-Japanese → kanji-written; analysis = Argument Transfer.

Opaque vs compositional compounds

Compositionality facts = REAL. Givón-style “eroded syntax” reading = SPECULATIVE mnemonic.

Compositional end — morphography working

CompoundPartsPattern
国道こくどうcountry + roadModifier + modified
登山とざんclimb + mountainverb + complement
外食がいしょくoutside + eatcomplement + verb
変化へんかchange + changesynonymous pair

Some encode predicate–argument relations inside the word — lexical packaging of event structure.

Phonetic borrowing — no morphographic constituency

Ateji / phonetic 葡萄ぶどう · 面倒めんどう budō ‘grapes’; mendō ‘care / bother’ — graphs do not contribute live morpheme composition (Joyce / Honda)

Bleaching — the fossil zone

勉強 /benkyō/ ‘study’ 勉べん + 強きょう → 勉強べんきょう Naive sum ‘strive + strength’; modern meaning ‘study’. Compositionality decreased (Honda). Speakers need not compute the parts.
挨拶 /aisatsu/ ‘greeting’ 挨拶あいさつ Historical compositionality — and morphological constituency — lost (Honda). Prefer: opaque lexeme written with two graphs; not two live morphemes; not cran-operators.
Jukujikun 田舎いなか ‘countryside’ — complex graph string ↔ one phonological exponent; morphography of the parts suspended
SPECULATIVE · Givón mnemonic. Older compositional word-formation eroded into a simplex lexical package.
Sources. Honda 2019 §§3.2.1–3.2.2; Joyce 2011 (via Honda). Opaque compounds support the morphology waypoint (“spell-out can freeze”),